3P-050 — Led Zeppelin (1969)

Led Zeppelin

1 — Arguably the greatest drum intro of all time. And I don’t care what the neighbors say.2 — Lots of keyboard solos in rock, but none sound remotely like how John Paul Jones killed it on Your Time Is Gonna Come. Not to mention that this song is one of the great “fuck you” songs ever recorded.3 — While Zep I is mostly balls to the wall, Black Mountain Side is a hypnotic trance-like interlude. Close your eyes and let Page take you away.

VERDICT

Come on, it’s Zeppelin’s debut. Good times only.

3P-050 — Led Zeppelin (1969)

Led Zeppelin

1 — Arguably the greatest drum intro of all time. And I don’t care what the neighbors say.2 — Lots of keyboard solos in rock, but none sound remotely like how John Paul Jones killed it on Your Time Is Gonna Come. Not to mention that this song is one of the great “fuck you” songs ever recorded.3 — While Zep I is mostly balls to the wall, Black Mountain Side is a hypnotic trance-like interlude. Close your eyes and let Page take you away.

VERDICT

Come on, it’s Zeppelin’s debut. Good times only.

3P-049 — Obscured by Clouds (1972)

Pink Floyd

1 — This is the Pink Floyd album before Dark Side.2 — Hot off of Meddle, OBC is a radical departure from the breadth of Echoes and One of These Days. Replete with pop-length songs and more conventional arrangements, but by no means a sneak peek of DSOTM.3 — Wot’s…Uh the Deal rises to the level of Wish You Were Here, and if released after Dark Side, this track may have surpassed it in popularity. Top ten Floyd song of all time.

VERDICT

Definitely worth listening to the album that preceded the magnum opus.

3P-048 — Ram (1971)

Paul McCartney, Linda McCartney

1 — Unappreciated in its time—seminal today. Without Ram, there’d be no R.E.M., no Wilco, and the like. Don’t believe me, just check out Eat at Home. Or Too Many People. Or just the whole album.2 — Seriously, is Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey Paul’s best song ever? I’m not saying your favorite, I’m saying his best. What plane of genius was Paul on when he wrote that? To listen to that song again for the very first time—and not know what’s to come—would be a delight.3 — And on top of Ram’s poetic mastery, it’s Paul’s anger letter to John. Oh dear boy!

VERDICT

Contrary to popular belief, this is the greatest solo Beatles record of all time. Yeah, I said it! [gauntlet thrown]

3P-047 — Plastic Ono Band (1970)

John Lennon

1 — The ultimate catharsis record. If you’re sad, mad, or simply lost, listen to this record and hold on—it’s going to be alright.2 — Look at me, here I am…
I don’t expect you to understand…
I was the walrus, but now I’m John…
I just got to tell you, goodbye…
The dream is over…And that’s just a sample of his pain.3 — Plastic Ono Band is more than a collection of Lennon songs. It’s John’s soul exposed and laid bare for the world to see post-Beatles breakup. It’s scary and it’s beautiful.

VERDICT

A masterpiece. Contrary to popular belief, this is the best Beatle solo record of 1970.

3P-046 — Graceland (1986)

Paul Simon

1 — 80s staple that is pure joy and so much more than the songs you know.2 — Best accordion album intro in the history of rock and roll!3 — I Know What I Know is the secret high point of this record—and I do know you from the cinematographer’s party.

VERDICT

Make the pilgrimage to Graceland.

3P-045 — WE (2022)

Arcade Fire

1 — WE striking a chord not heard since The Suburbs.2 — Why can’t all new Arcade Fire capture the moment like Lightning I and II3 — Unconditional I is the pick me up we all need.

VERDICT

“Nothing is ever perfect,” but solid AF record. Worth a few spins.

3P-044 — Violent Femmes (1983)

Violent Femmes

1 — Add Blister in the Sun to list of all-time iconic album openers. Its distinctive opening riff can be named in five notes.2 — Wanna let out your frustrations… Listen to Kiss Off loud and belt out every word.3 — This album answers the age old question: Why can’t I get just one fuck?

VERDICT

"10,10,10,10 for everything everything, everything, everything, everything!!!”

3P-043 — Weezer (1994)

Weezer

1 — A staple in most collections, the blue album that ushered in geek rock holds up surprisingly strong today. And yeah, Sweater Song still rocks…2 — Without a doubt, there is no greater 1990s guitar hook than the crescendo of Buddy Holly —Baarrrn-Naarrr-Naarrr-Naar-Naar-Naar-Narr—You know what I’m talking about.3 — Say It Ain’t So is an alt-rock jewel—Turn it up, primal scream, clench your fists, even drink a glass of milk and not wipe the excess off your face!

VERDICT

The world has turned and this album is still here—and astounding. Revisit and reassert your inner nerd.

3P-042 — War (1983)

U2

1 — U2’s standout third outing is a kick-ass, take no prisoners, mother-effin rock show that’s a must-have in any collection.2 — Not many albums open stronger than Sunday Bloody Sunday—let alone a generational anthem. Mullen’s drums. The Edge’s guitar. Alright, let’s go.3 — “How long must we sing this song?”
...“How long to sing this song?”
Answer: like a song you have to sing.

VERDICT

The golden age. Sing it loud, play it again—and maybe stop to dance.

3P-041 — Black Eyed Man (1992)

Cowboy Junkies

1 — A must-listen from Canada’s sibling band exploring America’s South.2 — Michael Timmins’ hypnotic guitar casts a spell. But it’s Margo Timmins’ raspy vocals that take you to that other place. A lot of singers have pipes—but there is only one Margo Timmins.3 — Don’t believe the 3P hype—Horse in the Country, Oregon Hill, and Southern Rain. You’re welcome.

VERDICT

This is how I discovered the Junkies. Saddle up and ride away.

3P-040 — The Doors (1967)

The Doors

1 — The debut that put the Doors on the map—with permanent marker.2 — You know that signature electric piano? It starts here. And yes—this is the one with Light My Fire.3 — The End. Oedipal masterpiece.

VERDICT

Slip into unconsciousness again and again. I’ll meet you at the back of the blue bus.

3P-039 — Tonight (2009)

Franz Ferdinand

1 — Groovy third outing from the UK’s hidden pearl that leaves you asking—how do I not know this?2 — Ulysses—opening bass, the build, the whisper, then the trip. Find a new way, baby!3 — Synthesizer galore—Can’t Stop Feeling, Live Alone, and the 8-minute rave-alternative opus, Lucid Dreams.

VERDICT

Take a break from Radiohead and check this out. Skip if you dislike synths.

3P-038 — Moondance (1970)

Van Morrison

1 — Oh the water!!! No other Van album tops this one. Not many classics are truly flawless—Moondance is.2 — Go beyond the ones you know—Glad tidings from New York, caravans painted red and white, fantabulous night to make romance.3 — Into the Mystic. No need to comment further. Listen, love—too late to stop now.

VERDICT

Whether it rocks your gypsy soul or stones you to your soul, come running. Turn it up.

3P-037 — Sticky Fingers (1971)

The Rolling Stones

1 — The perfect Stones concoction on one record—though some may exile me for Main Street.2 — That opening riff of Brown Sugar. Buhh! Buhh! Buh-buh-ba-bu-h!!! Whoo!!!3 — Can’t You Hear Me Knocking? Fuck yeah we can.

VERDICT

Drunk, juiced up, and sloppy—in the best way. One of the Stones’ all-time gangbusters!

3P-036 — Synchronicity (1983)

The Police

1 — Lyrical metaphors everywhere—but nothing hits like rush hour: lemmings packed in shiny metal boxes.2 — Mother—no. Miss Gradenko—yes. Synchronicity I and II—more.3 — Like it or not, there’d be no Radiohead without Murder by Numbers. Andy Summers’ guitar here is the birth of Johnny Greenwood.

VERDICT

Mighty swan song from the greatest rock trio. This little black spot on the sun burnt out too soon.

3P-035 — Absolution (2003)

Muse

1 — A nonstop barrage of sound—Muse making it clear early they have something to say, loudly.2 — Stockholm Syndrome spirals, Falling Away with You aches, and nothing small about The Small Print.3 — Apocalypse Please is absolutely bonkers.

VERDICT

Off its rocker. Proclaim eternal victory.

3P-034 — So (1986)

Peter Gabriel

1 — Peter Gabriel’s commercial peak—and it was about time. Arguably the last great album of the 1980–1986 era.2 — “Let the red rain pour down on me…” Helluva opener. If this doesn’t grab you, change the record.3 — That Voice Again…play it again. Maybe the finest song here—though some will hit me with a sledgehammer for that.

VERDICT

It may not be Biko or Games Without Frontiers, but so what. Primo record.

3P-033 — Singles–45’s and Under (1982)

Squeeze

1 — Classic greatest hits record from one of the most underrated bands—and songwriters—in rock history. Every song on this sampler is a can’t miss.2 — Tellies, Tenners, Tellies, and Nappies—there are songs with stories to tell, and in a league of its own, there’s Up the Junction.3 — You know Tempted. You love Tempted. Now go meet the rest.

VERDICT

Definitely cool for cats. Explore this band and feel the need for Squeeze.

3P-032 — Blood on the Tracks (1975)

Bob Dylan

1 — Smack dab in the middle of Dylan’s ’70s renaissance. Oh, this is a good one.2 — That opening acoustic guitar—you know the song. Sit back, you’re on a Dylan odyssey. “Working for a while on a fishing boat right outside of Delacroix.” It may be his finest.3 — These songs ache, weep, and bleed. A lyrical tour de force—it’s a wonder I even know how to breathe.

VERDICT

Hands down, in the top echelon of Dylan. But if you love lyrics, this one may be tip-top. Listen carefully.

3P-031 — In Utero (1993)

Nirvana

1 — Kurt. Cool. Classic.2 — Some tracks are pure genius—and truly exceed those on its era-defining predecessor. A few tracks are a bit more challenging to embrace.3 — I don’t know what “aqua seafoam shame” is, but I love it—and every other sad, drug-soaked image in the closing track. No apologies necessary.

VERDICT

I have a love-hate relationship with a few tracks, but the record is gangbusters.

3P-030 — Siamese Dream (1993)

The Smashing Pumpkins

1 — This is The Smashing Pumpkins’ zenith. Nothing from that era sounds like this album.2 — Soma is from a brave new world. Mayonaise is delicious. Today is the greatest.3 — The closer, Luna, leaves you wanting more. Yes, I’m so in love with you (so in love).

VERDICT

Trippy, heavy, and an absolute dream. Play it loud.

3P-029 — Imperial Bedroom (1982)

Elvis Costello, The Attractions

1 — Another apex from the most underrated rock star. Elvis is king.2 — One of the great album openers—and it’s not even his best. Few albums don’t have a skip—this is one of them.3 — And then there’s Man Out of Time—the WTF primal scream, the crazed guitar, the return to the classic Attractions sound. But wait…what is he even singing about? Take a listen—and ask if you’ll still love a man out of time.

VERDICT

Beyond belief. Start to finish.

3P-028 — Flaming Pie (1997)

Paul McCartney

1 — Whoa, where did this Paul record come from? Fresh off the Beatles Anthology, Paul drops his most confident record in decades—echoing the spirit of early 1970s Macca.2 — Great Day—Could sit on Ram without blinking. Simple as that.3 — Beautiful Night—Ringo and George Martin back in the room. Modest lyrics, but the arrangement is flawless. Lordy, lordy.

VERDICT

An unexpected late-career gem. Not perfect—but far better than it has any right to be.

3P-027 — Bookends (1968)

Simon & Garfunkel

1 — Coo-coo-ca-choo, Mrs. Robinson. Without a doubt the second-best S&G record. Don’t get too comfortable with the acoustic opener—this thing turns quickly: a trippy dilemma, idiosyncratic zoo animals, and the “blah, blah, blah….”2 — Greyhound bus. New Jersey Turnpike. Empty and aching and don’t know why—perfection.3 — More Old Friends. Less Voices of Old People. You’ll know it when you hear it. Permission to skip.

VERDICT

It may not be Bridge Over Troubled Water, but this one delivers—start to finish, minus one.

3P-026 — The Nylon Curtain (1982)

Billy Joel

1 — Less appreciated Billy Joel classic album that deserves real love. On par with 52nd Street and Glass Houses, but never in the same conversation.2 — Following up Glass Houses (and Songs in the Attic) should be no easy feat, but Billy’s experimental, Beatle-esque record is a tour de force with the classics you love—Pressure, Goodnight Saigon, Allentown—and the classics you don’t know yet—Surprises, She’s Right on Time…3 — And then there’s Laura—how this is not Billy’s most popular song is beyond comprehension. Turn it up loud.

VERDICT

The last Billy Joel record before the Brinkley pivot deserves more attention than it gets. Take my Peter Pan advice.

3P-025 — Led Zeppelin III (1970)

Led Zeppelin

1 — The Zep bridge album between the all-time classic and the pinnacle of rock.2 — Iconic opener. That riff, that Scream, that beat. Don’t need to be a Zep fan to recognize this.3 — Tangerine is one of the band’s greats. If any other band created Tangerine, even if it was their only hit, they’d go down in rock history. For Zeppelin, Tangerine is just another song in a very large ocean of preeminence.

VERDICT

The third record sometimes gets lost in Zep’s legendary run through Physical Graffiti, but it deserves some attention too.

3P-024 — Double Fantasy (1980)

John Lennon, Yoko Ono

1 -- Love half the album. Wish I could love the other half.2 -- The opening bells. Signature opener. For those who love John…a smile from the sinister opening bells on Plastic Ono Band.3 -- Watching the Wheels. It’s more than a song: It’s John. And for newbies, it’s fuckin’ amazing.

VERDICT

Not a perfect record but a glimpse into a legend’s third act and what should have been.

3P-023 — Hot August Night (1972)

Neil Diamond

1 -- Masterful live double album showcasing a roller coaster of sound and lyrics. A singer-songwriter at his greatest power.2 -- Opening track: What is this chatter…are they practicing…..wait, the show has started…..I thought this was a man on his guitar?...What are these strings?….shh! Shut up and listen! And that organ piping in, the acoustic guitar, the deepest drums—bum bum bum bum-bum-bum….the clackety-clack, and then the CRESCENDO. And that the electric guitar…THE APPLAUSE! And the first note Neil sings, da da dee dom. And then it’s for the races…3 -- I am…I said is one of the most powerful performances recorded live. What a finish to that one. I wish I was there.

VERDICT

Let me hear that, let me near that. Uncanny live album recording of what legends are made of. You can’t just listen. You awaken.

3P-022 — Tapestry (1971)

Carole King

1 -- Landmark singer-songwriter release. For newbies, the “where have I heard that before” record.2 -- If love doesn’t strike by the opener, Cupid hits hard by So Far Away.3 -- Many emulate. Few replicate. Carole hit this out of the park to the land where the honey runs.

VERDICT

Required listening. Feel the Earth move with this one.

3P-021 — Are You Experienced (1967)

The Jimi Hendrix Experience

1 -- Iconic opener. Two notes. Instantly memorable.2 -- If a waterfall sounded like an electric guitar led trio, Jimi nailed it.3 -- A fine debut for a guitarist who changed the game.

VERDICT

Move over Rover and let Jimi take over….what else is there to say!

3P-020 — Abbey Road (1969)

The Beatles

1 — The album that’s something so heavy, and ended a once-in-a-lifetime musical revolution. An undefinable classic.2 — The opener…the George explosions…the medley….the closer…the belly full of wine. ‘Nuff said.3 — Even the cover art is the greatest.

VERDICT

It doesn’t get much better than this. Oh, that magic feeling.

3P-019 — The Beatles (White Album) (1968)

The Beatles

1 — The double record every artist really wants to emulate. The rare record that grows with you. The unique record you never hear the same twice. You really can’t stop your brain.2 — Too many masterpieces to reference but George’s short guitar solo on Happiness is a Warm Gun may be one of his greatest.3 — So many tears I was searching, so many tears I was wasting… oh. OH!

VERDICT

There is no album like the White Album. And there never will be.

3P-018 — The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars (1972)

David Bowie

1 — The opener that changes everything…we’re on to something new. Is Earth really dying?2 — How can you describe an album that turned rock in its head. You can’t. Just listen.3 — Starman will give you chills; Moonage Daydream will make you jump; Rock n Roll Suicide will have you screaming for more. And those are not even the “hits.”

VERDICT

70s zeitgeist. League of its own. Wham bam thank you ma’am!

3P-017 — Dark Side of the Moon (1973)

Pink Floyd

1 — First there was Sgt. Pepper, then there was Dark Side….2 — If you don’t know this one, you definitely died before 1973. Or you were really drunk at the time….3 — Everything under the sun is in tune.

VERDICT

One of the greatest of all time. Never gets old. Timeless forever. Home, home again.

3P-016 — Thriller (1982)

Michael Jackson

1 —One of the highest selling records of all time.2 — More than half the songs are etched into pop music history3 — The opening synth to Billy Jean is burned in most people’s brains.

VERDICT

If you don’t know it, you lived in a society without music.

3P-015 — Genesis (Self-Titled) (1983)

Genesis

1 — Oh mama – the last Genesis record before the band goes full commercial.2 — Home by the Sea rivals Abacab as peak Collins era. Home by the Sea takes you down a far more sinister musical voyage, but nothing as sinister as the Collins’ laugh in Mama.3 — Conversely, half the album is bright and a sign of what’s to come. But Silver Rainbow doesn’t get enough love.

VERDICT

Enjoy the final bow of classic Genesis. That’s all.

3P-014 — Automatic for the People (1992)

R.E.M.

1 — Hey kids, rock n roll….R.E.M.’s apex of their most dominant decade.2 — From the first guitar riff, R.E.M. is sending a clear message—this is not your shiny happy people. The musical pivot makes this album feel timeless.3 — R.E.M. has so many classics but Find the River should enter that conversation.

VERDICT

Ollie Ollie Ollie. Own it, love it, repeat.

3P-013 — Who’s Next (1971)

The Who

1 — Meet the new boss, same as the old boss: Not many artists can say the follow-up to their signature album is even better. The Who can…2 — Oh and that opener….the synth….three piano notes… Keith’s drums…Roger’s first lyric…John’s root….and then Pete’s riff….and stop! Don’t cry, it’s just teenage wasteland….3 — A flawless track list with multiple anthems of a generation. And an infamous album cover to boot—peeing on a stone monolith.

VERDICT

Right in tune. Play it loud. Play it often.

3P-012 — Funeral (2004)

Arcade Fire

1 — Prepare for the chills: the opening notes…then the first lyric…oh yeah, we’re going somewhere….but it builds, and it builds….we’re on a journey but now I’m scared about going there…but I can’t turn away.2 — If any song in music has the depth of an entire album, it’s Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels).3 — A masterful debut that hasn’t lost a beat, particularly the coda of Crown of Love.

VERDICT

An impassioned voyage of sound and lyrics that by the end you may need a seat…boy what a ride.

3P-011 — 1984 (1984)

Van Halen

1 — Feel the 80s synth flow and Jump! It’s ok, I’ll Wait.2 — Drop Dead Legs—classic Eddie and David Lee….strong as any earlier track.3 — Opening drums to kick off side two. Doesn’t get much better than this.

VERDICT

Not I or II, but quintessential for its time. Don’t forget to come back to this one. Class dismissed.

3P-010 — Purple Rain (1984)

Prince & The Revolution

1 — Dearly beloved, we may have the best opening track ever. Four enchanting minutes of pure catharsis.2 — It doesn’t stop…Take Me With U, Beautiful Ones…and that’s just side one. Side two...oh God yes.3 — This belongs in the highest echelon of 20th century artistry.

VERDICT

Perfect album. Rare and beautiful.

3P-009 — Let it Bleed (1969)

The Rolling Stones

1 — One of the great album openings ever. Opening riff of Gimme Shelter and we’re off.2 — Title track is the Stones off their rocker! Give those lyrics a second listen…sounds like quite a trip.3 — First piano notes of Monkey Man and you know the Stones did it again. Sublime.

VERDICT

While not perfect, this overlooked gem deserves more cred than it gets. Give it what it needs!

3P-008 — Kiss All the Time. Disco, Occasionally (2026)

Harry Styles

1 — If you’re all about classic rock and Radiohead, but still musically curious, check this one out right now!2 — Paint by numbers, Coming up Roses, and Taste Back show depth that confirms HS is more than a pop star.3 — Hard to stop playing once started.

VERDICT

Modern classic. Gen X listen at least five times before judgment.

3P-007 — Open (2001)

Cowboy Junkies

1 — May be Cowboy Junkies’ finest moment.2 — If Sweet Jane is the introduction, I Did It All for You is the closer. You can’t go back.3 — The album is a scare and a love letter. How does Margo evoke fear and love at the same time??

VERDICT

Dim the lights, take a deep breath, and relax. Keep heavy on rotation.

3P-006 — Wish You Were Here (1975)

Pink Floyd

1 — How can you follow Dark Side of the Moon? The answer is here in 5 songs.2 — Gilmour and that guitar!! Which one’s Pink? Fishbowl living. Shining on your seer of visions….whoa…3 — Melt away during the bookends of Shine on…and relish the juicy depth in between.

VERDICT

Put on repeat…forever.

3P-005 — Revolver (1966)

The Beatles

1 — It doesn’t get much better than this.2 — Without Revolver, there’d be no Dark Side, no Nevermind, no Radiohead…and no Beatles that we worship today.3 — The juxtaposition of Here, There, and Everywhere, Yellow Submarine, and She Said She Said….[speechless jaw drop]

VERDICT

My all-time favorite. ‘Nuff said.

3P-004 — Rumours (1977)

Fleetwood Mac

1 — An artistic - and highly commercial - classic for the ages.2 — How do you not get jazzed when Second Hand News amps up?3 — The excellence is endless: flawless songs, real heartbreak, no filler.

VERDICT

Bam-bam ba-ba-bam bam bam bam—must own!

3P-003 — Legend (1984 Compilation)

Bob Marley & The Wailers

1 — Essential staple of any music collection.2 — No single track rises above the others — they’re all classics.3 — In an era full of “best of” albums, this one is genuinely flawless.

VERDICT

Listening required - Must have for those who don’t have.

3P-002 — OK Computer (1997)

Radiohead

1 — The beginning of the Radiohead revolution.2 — Paranoid Android’s haunting middle 8 grabs you and lever let’s go.3 — While Nevermind may be the crown jewel of the 1990s, OK Computer may be its Sgt. Pepper.

VERDICT

Listen now - with headphones.

3P-001 — Turnstiles (1976)

Billy Joel

1 — Billy Joel’s understated masterpiece that quietly rivals The Stranger, if not surpasses it.2 — This may be his finest collection of songs on one album. Say Goodbye to Hollywood—quotable and full of hellos and goodbyes. Summer, Highland Falls—his most underrated track. Prelude/Angry Young Man—with one of the greatest (and fastest) piano intros ever. And New York State of Mind—an anthem.3 — And then there was I’ve Loved These Days. Every line is a soundbite. Still feels written for today. Sing it loud.

VERDICT

An underappreciated classic. Impeccable from beginning to end.

3P-025 — Led Zeppelin III (1970)

Led Zeppelin

1 -- The Zep bridge album between the all-time classic and the pinnacle of rock.2 -- Iconic opener. That riff, that Scream, that beat. Don’t need to be a Zep fan to recognize this.3 --Tangerine is one of the band’s greats. If any other band created Tangerine, even if it was their only hit, they’d go down in rock history. For Zeppelin, Tangerine is just another song in a very large ocean of preeminence.

VERDICT

The third record sometimes gets lost in Zep’s legendary run through Physical Graffiti, but it deserves some attention too.

3P-025 — Led Zeppelin III (1970)

Led Zeppelin

1 -- The Zep bridge album between the all-time classic and the pinnacle of rock.2 -- Iconic opener. That riff, that Scream, that beat. Don’t need to be a Zep fan to recognize this.3 --Tangerine is one of the band’s greats. If any other band created Tangerine, even if it was their only hit, they’d go down in rock history. For Zeppelin, Tangerine is just another song in a very large ocean of preeminence.

VERDICT

The third record sometimes gets lost in Zep’s legendary run through Physical Graffiti, but it deserves some attention too.

3P-024 — Double Fantasy (1980)

John Lennon, Yoko Ono

1. Love half the album. Wish I could love the other half.2. The opening bells. Signature opener. For those who love John…a smile from the sinister opening bells on Plastic Ono Band.3. Watching the Wheels. It’s more than a song: It’s John. And for newbies, it’s fuckin’ amazing.

VERDICT

Not a perfect record but a glimpse into a legend’s third act and what should have been.

3P-005 — Revolver (1966)

The Beatles

1 — It doesn’t get much better than this.2 — Without Revolver, there’d be no Dark Side, no Nevermind, no Radiohead…and no Beatles that we worship today.3 — The juxtaposition of Here, There, and Everywhere, Yellow Submarine, and She Said She Said….[speechless jaw drop]

VERDICT

My all-time favorite. ‘Nuff said.

3P-009 — Let it Bleed (1969)

The Rolling Stones

1 — One of the great album openings ever. Opening riff of Gimme Shelter and we’re off.2 — Title track is the Stones off their rocker! Give those lyrics a second listen…sounds like quite a trip.3 — First piano notes of Monkey Man and you know the Stones did it again. Sublime.

VERDICT

While not perfect, this overlooked gem deserves more cred than it gets. Give it what it needs!

3P-019 — The Beatles (White Album) (1968)

The Beatles

1 — The double record every artist really wants to emulate. The rare record that grows with you. The unique record you never hear the same twice. You really can’t stop your brain.2 — Too many masterpieces to reference but George’s short guitar solo on Happiness is a Warm Gun may be one of his greatest.3 — So many tears I was searching, so many tears I was wasting… oh. OH!

VERDICT

There is no album like the White Album. And there never will be.

3P-020 — Abbey Road (1969)

The Beatles

1 — The album that’s something so heavy, and ended a once-in-a-lifetime musical revolution. An undefinable classic.2 — The opener…the George explosions…the medley….the closer…the belly full of wine. ‘Nuff said.3 — Even the cover art is the greatest.

VERDICT

It doesn’t get much better than this. Oh, that magic feeling.

3P-021 — Are You Experienced (1967)

The Jimi Hendrix Experience

1 -- Iconic opener. Two notes. Instantly memorable.2 -- If a waterfall sounded like an electric guitar led trio, Jimi nailed it.3 -- A fine debut for a guitarist who changed the game.

VERDICT

Move over Rover and let Jimi take over….what else is there to say!

3P-027 — Bookends (1968)

Simon & Garfunkel

1 — Coo-coo-ca-choo, Mrs. Robinson. Without a doubt the second-best S&G record. Don’t get too comfortable with the acoustic opener—this thing turns quickly: a trippy dilemma, idiosyncratic zoo animals, and the “blah, blah, blah….”2 — Greyhound bus. New Jersey Turnpike. Empty and aching and don’t know why—perfection.3 — More Old Friends. Less Voices of Old People. You’ll know it when you hear it. Permission to skip.

VERDICT

It may not be Bridge Over Troubled Water, but this one delivers—start to finish, minus one.

3P-040 — The Doors (1967)

The Doors

1 — The debut that put the Doors on the map—with permanent marker.2 — You know that signature electric piano? It starts here. And yes—this is the one with Light My Fire.3 — The End. Oedipal masterpiece.

VERDICT

Slip into unconsciousness again and again. I’ll meet you at the back of the blue bus.

3P-050 — Led Zeppelin (1969)

Led Zeppelin

1 — Arguably the greatest drum intro of all time. And I don’t care what the neighbors say.2 — Lots of keyboard solos in rock, but none sound remotely like how John Paul Jones killed it on Your Time Is Gonna Come. Not to mention that this song is one of the great “fuck you” songs ever recorded.3 — While Zep I is mostly balls to the wall, Black Mountain Side is a hypnotic trance-like interlude. Close your eyes and let Page take you away.

VERDICT

Come on, it’s Zeppelin’s debut. Good times only.

3P-001 — Turnstiles (1976)

Billy Joel

1 — Billy Joel’s understated masterpiece that quietly rivals The Stranger, if not surpasses it.2 — This may be his finest collection of songs on one album. Say Goodbye to Hollywood—quotable and full of hellos and goodbyes. Summer, Highland Falls—his most underrated track. Prelude/Angry Young Man—with one of the greatest (and fastest) piano intros ever. And New York State of Mind—an anthem.3 — And then there was I’ve Loved These Days. Every line is a soundbite. Still feels written for today. Sing it loud.

VERDICT

An underappreciated classic. Impeccable from beginning to end.

3P-004 — Rumours (1977)

Fleetwood Mac

1 — An artistic - and highly commercial - classic for the ages.2 — How do you not get jazzed when Second Hand News amps up?3 — The excellence is endless: flawless songs, real heartbreak, no filler.

VERDICT

Bam-bam ba-ba-bam bam bam bam—must own!

3P-006 — Wish You Were Here (1975)

Pink Floyd

1 — How can you follow Dark Side of the Moon? The answer is here in 5 songs.2 — Gilmour and that guitar!! Which one’s Pink? Fishbowl living. Shining on your seer of visions….whoa…3 — Melt away during the bookends of Shine on…and relish the juicy depth in between.

VERDICT

Put on repeat…forever.

3P-013 — Who’s Next (1971)

The Who

1 — Meet the new boss, same as the old boss: Not many artists can say the follow-up to their signature album is even better. The Who can…2 — Oh and that opener….the synth….three piano notes… Keith’s drums…Roger’s first lyric…John’s root….and then Pete’s riff….and stop! Don’t cry, it’s just teenage wasteland….3 — A flawless track list with multiple anthems of a generation. And an infamous album cover to boot—peeing on a stone monolith.

VERDICT

Right in tune. Play it loud. Play it often.

3P-017 — Dark Side of the Moon (1973)

Pink Floyd

1 — First there was Sgt. Pepper, then there was Dark Side….2 — If you don’t know this one, you definitely died before 1973. Or you were really drunk at the time….3 — Everything under the sun is in tune.

VERDICT

One of the greatest of all time. Never gets old. Timeless forever. Home, home again.

3P-018 — The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars (1972)

David Bowie

1 — The opener that changes everything…we’re on to something new. Is Earth really dying?2 — How can you describe an album that turned rock in its head. You can’t. Just listen.3 — Starman will give you chills; Moonage Daydream will make you jump; Rock n Roll Suicide will have you screaming for more. And those are not even the “hits.”

VERDICT

70s zeitgeist. League of its own. Wham bam thank you ma’am!

3P-022 — Tapestry (1971)

Carole King

1 -- Landmark singer-songwriter release. For newbies, the “where have I heard that before” record.2 -- If love doesn’t strike by the opener, Cupid hits hard by So Far Away.3 -- Many emulate. Few replicate. Carole hit this out of the park to the land where the honey runs.

VERDICT

Required listening. Feel the Earth move with this one.

3P-023 — Hot August Night (1972)

Neil Diamond

1 -- Masterful live double album showcasing a roller coaster of sound and lyrics. A singer-songwriter at his greatest power.2 -- Opening track: What is this chatter…are they practicing…..wait, the show has started…..I thought this was a man on his guitar?...What are these strings?….shh! Shut up and listen! And that organ piping in, the acoustic guitar, the deepest drums—bum bum bum bum-bum-bum….the clackety-clack, and then the CRESCENDO. And that the electric guitar…THE APPLAUSE! And the first note Neil sings, da da dee dom. And then it’s for the races…3 -- I am…I said is one of the most powerful performances recorded live. What a finish to that one. I wish I was there.

VERDICT

Let me hear that, let me near that. Uncanny live album recording of what legends are made of. You can’t just listen. You awaken.

3P-025 — Led Zeppelin III (1970)

Led Zeppelin

1 — The Zep bridge album between the all-time classic and the pinnacle of rock.2 — Iconic opener. That riff, that Scream, that beat. Don’t need to be a Zep fan to recognize this.3 — Tangerine is one of the band’s greats. If any other band created Tangerine, even if it was their only hit, they’d go down in rock history. For Zeppelin, Tangerine is just another song in a very large ocean of preeminence.

VERDICT

The third record sometimes gets lost in Zep’s legendary run through Physical Graffiti, but it deserves some attention too.

3P-032 — Blood on the Tracks (1975)

Bob Dylan

1 — Smack dab in the middle of Dylan’s ’70s renaissance. Oh, this is a good one.2 — That opening acoustic guitar—you know the song. Sit back, you’re on a Dylan odyssey. “Working for a while on a fishing boat right outside of Delacroix.” It may be his finest.3 — These songs ache, weep, and bleed. A lyrical tour de force—it’s a wonder I even know how to breathe.

VERDICT

Hands down, in the top echelon of Dylan. But if you love lyrics, this one may be tip-top. Listen carefully.

3P-037 — Sticky Fingers (1971)

The Rolling Stones

1 — The perfect Stones concoction on one record—though some may exile me for Main Street.2 — That opening riff of Brown Sugar. Buhh! Buhh! Buh-buh-ba-bu-h!!! Whoo!!!3 — Can’t You Hear Me Knocking? Fuck yeah we can.

VERDICT

Drunk, juiced up, and sloppy—in the best way. One of the Stones’ all-time gangbusters!

3P-038 — Moondance (1970)

Van Morrison

1 — Oh the water!!! No other Van album tops this one. Not many classics are truly flawless—Moondance is.2 — Go beyond the ones you know—Glad tidings from New York, caravans painted red and white, fantabulous night to make romance.3 — Into the Mystic
. No need to comment further. Listen, love—too late to stop now.

VERDICT

Whether it rocks your gypsy soul or stones you to your soul, come running. Turn it up.

3P-047 — Plastic Ono Band (1970)

John Lennon

1 — The ultimate catharsis record. If you’re sad, mad, or simply lost, listen to this record and hold on—it’s going to be alright.2 — Look at me, here I am…
I don’t expect you to understand…
I was the walrus, but now I’m John…
I just got to tell you, goodbye…
The dream is over…And that’s just a sample of his pain.3 — Plastic Ono Band is more than a collection of Lennon songs. It’s John’s soul exposed and laid bare for the world to see post-Beatles breakup. It’s scary and it’s beautiful.

VERDICT

A masterpiece. Contrary to popular belief, this is the best Beatle solo record of 1970.

3P-048 — Ram (1971)

Paul McCartney, Linda McCartney

1 — Unappreciated in its time—seminal today. Without Ram, there’d be no R.E.M., no Wilco, and the like. Don’t believe me, just check out Eat at Home. Or Too Many People. Or just the whole album.2 — Seriously, is Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey Paul’s best song ever? I’m not saying your favorite, I’m saying his best. What plane of genius was Paul on when he wrote that? To listen to that song again for the very first time—and not know what’s to come—would be a delight.3 — And on top of Ram’s poetic mastery, it’s Paul’s anger letter to John. Oh dear boy!

VERDICT

Contrary to popular belief, this is the greatest solo Beatles record of all time. Yeah, I said it! [gauntlet thrown]

3P-049 — Obscured by Clouds (1972)

Pink Floyd

1 — This is the Pink Floyd album before Dark Side.2 — Hot off of Meddle, OBC is a radical departure from the breadth of Echoes and One of These Days. Replete with pop-length songs and more conventional arrangements, but by no means a sneak peek of DSOTM.3 — Wot’s…Uh the Deal rises to the level of Wish You Were Here, and if released after Dark Side, this track may have surpassed it in popularity. Top ten Floyd song of all time.

VERDICT

Definitely worth listening to the album that preceded the magnum opus.

Three POINTS1980s

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-003 — Legend (1984 Compilation)

Bob Marley & The Wailers

1 — Essential staple of any music collection.2 — No single track rises above the others — they’re all classics.3 — In an era full of “best of” albums, this one is genuinely flawless.

VERDICT

Listening required - Must have for those who don’t have.

3P-010 — Purple Rain (1984)

Prince & The Revolution

1 — Dearly beloved, we may have the best opening track ever. Four enchanting minutes of pure catharsis.2 — It doesn’t stop…Take Me With U, Beautiful Ones…and that’s just side one. Side two...oh God yes.3 — This belongs in the highest echelon of 20th century artistry.

VERDICT

Perfect album. Rare and beautiful.

3P-011 — 1984 (1984)

Van Halen

1 — Feel the 80s synth flow and Jump! It’s ok, I’ll Wait.2 — Drop Dead Legs—classic Eddie and David Lee….strong as any earlier track.3 — Opening drums to kick off side two. Doesn’t get much better than this.

VERDICT

Not I or II, but quintessential for its time. Don’t forget to come back to this one. Class dismissed.

3P-015 — Genesis (Self-Titled) (1983)

Genesis

1 — Oh mama – the last Genesis record before the band goes full commercial.2 — Home by the Sea rivals Abacab as peak Collins era. Home by the Sea takes you down a far more sinister musical voyage, but nothing as sinister as the Collins’ laugh in Mama.3 — Conversely, half the album is bright and a sign of what’s to come. But Silver Rainbow doesn’t get enough love.

VERDICT

Enjoy the final bow of classic Genesis. That’s all.

3P-016 — Thriller (1982)

Michael Jackson

1 —One of the highest selling records of all time.2 — More than half the songs are etched into pop music history3 — The opening synth to Billy Jean is burned in most people’s brains.

VERDICT

If you don’t know it, you lived in a society without music.

3P-024 — Double Fantasy (1980)

John Lennon, Yoko Ono

1 -- Love half the album. Wish I could love the other half.2 -- The opening bells. Signature opener. For those who love John…a smile from the sinister opening bells on Plastic Ono Band.3 -- Watching the Wheels. It’s more than a song: It’s John. And for newbies, it’s fuckin’ amazing.

VERDICT

Not a perfect record but a glimpse into a legend’s third act and what should have been.

3P-026 — The Nylon Curtain (1982)

Billy Joel

1 — Less appreciated Billy Joel classic album that deserves real love. On par with 52nd Street and Glass Houses, but never in the same conversation.2 — Following up Glass Houses (and Songs in the Attic) should be no easy feat, but Billy’s experimental, Beatle-esque record is a tour de force with the classics you love—Pressure, Goodnight Saigon, Allentown—and the classics you don’t know yet—Surprises, She’s Right on Time…3 — And then there’s Laura—how this is not Billy’s most popular song is beyond comprehension. Turn it up loud.

VERDICT

The last Billy Joel record before the Brinkley pivot deserves more attention than it gets. Take my Peter Pan advice.

3P-029 — Imperial Bedroom (1982)

Elvis Costello, The Attractions

1 — Another apex from the most underrated rock star. Elvis is king.2 — One of the great album openers—and it’s not even his best. Few albums don’t have a skip—this is one of them.3 — And then there’s Man Out of Time—the WTF primal scream, the crazed guitar, the return to the classic Attractions sound. But wait…what is he even singing about? Take a listen—and ask if you’ll still love a man out of time.

VERDICT

Beyond belief. Start to finish.

3P-033 — Singles–45’s and Under (1982)

Squeeze

1 — Classic greatest hits record from one of the most underrated bands—and songwriters—in rock history. Every song on this sampler is a can’t miss.2 — Tellies, Tenners, Tellies, and Nappies—there are songs with stories to tell, and in a league of its own, there’s Up the Junction.3 — You know Tempted. You love Tempted. Now go meet the rest.

VERDICT

Definitely cool for cats. Explore this band and feel the need for Squeeze.

3P-034 — So (1986)

Peter Gabriel

1 — Peter Gabriel’s commercial peak—and it was about time. Arguably the last great album of the 1980–1986 era.2 — “Let the red rain pour down on me…” Helluva opener. If this doesn’t grab you, change the record.3 — That Voice Again…play it again. Maybe the finest song here—though some will hit me with a sledgehammer for that.

VERDICT

It may not be Biko or Games Without Frontiers, but so what. Primo record.

3P-036 — Synchronicity (1983)

The Police

1 — Lyrical metaphors everywhere—but nothing hits like rush hour: lemmings packed in shiny metal boxes.2 — Mother—no. Miss Gradenko—yes. Synchronicity I and II—more.3 — Like it or not, there’d be no Radiohead without Murder by Numbers. Andy Summers’ guitar here is the birth of Johnny Greenwood.

VERDICT

Mighty swan song from the greatest rock trio. This little black spot on the sun burnt out too soon.

3P-042 — War (1983)

U2

1 — U2’s standout third outing is a kick-ass, take no prisoners, mother-effin rock show that’s a must-have in any collection.2 — Not many albums open stronger than Sunday Bloody Sunday—let alone a generational anthem. Mullen’s drums. The Edge’s guitar. Alright, let’s go.3 — “How long must we sing this song?”
...“How long to sing this song?”
Answer: like a song you have to sing.

VERDICT

The golden age. Sing it loud, play it again—and maybe stop to dance.

3P-044 — Violent Femmes (1983)

Violent Femmes

1 — Add Blister in the Sun to list of all-time iconic album openers. Its distinctive opening riff can be named in five notes.2 — Wanna let out your frustrations… Listen to Kiss Off loud and belt out every word.3 — This album answers the age old question: Why can’t I get just one fuck?

VERDICT

"10,10,10,10 for everything everything, everything, everything, everything!!!”

3P-046 — Graceland (1986)

Paul Simon

1 — 80s staple that is pure joy and so much more than the songs you know.2 — Best accordion album intro in the history of rock and roll!3 — I Know What I Know is the secret high point of this record—and I do know you from the cinematographer’s party.

VERDICT

Make the pilgrimage to Graceland.

Three POINTS1990s

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-002 — OK Computer (1997)

Radiohead

1 — The beginning of the Radiohead revolution.2 — Paranoid Android’s haunting middle 8 grabs you and lever let’s go.3 — While Nevermind may be the crown jewel of the 1990s, OK Computer may be its Sgt. Pepper.

VERDICT

Listen now - with headphones.

3P-014 — Automatic for the People (1992)

R.E.M.

1 — Hey kids, rock n roll….R.E.M.’s apex of their most dominant decade.2 — From the first guitar riff, R.E.M. is sending a clear message—this is not your shiny happy people. The musical pivot makes this album feel timeless.3 — R.E.M. has so many classics but Find the River should enter that conversation.

VERDICT

Ollie Ollie Ollie. Own it, love it, repeat.

3P-028 — Flaming Pie (1997)

Paul McCartney

1 — Whoa, where did this Paul record come from? Fresh off the Beatles Anthology, Paul drops his most confident record in decades—echoing the spirit of early 1970s Macca.2 — Great Day—Could sit on Ram without blinking. Simple as that.3 — Beautiful Night—Ringo and George Martin back in the room. Modest lyrics, but the arrangement is flawless. Lordy, lordy.

VERDICT

An unexpected late-career gem. Not perfect—but far better than it has any right to be.

3P-030 — Siamese Dream (1993)

The Smashing Pumpkins

1 — This is The Smashing Pumpkins’ zenith. Nothing from that era sounds like this album.2 — Soma is from a brave new world. Mayonaise is delicious. Today is the greatest.3 — The closer, Luna, leaves you wanting more. Yes, I’m so in love with you (so in love).

VERDICT

Trippy, heavy, and an absolute dream. Play it loud.

3P-031 — In Utero (1993)

Nirvana

1 — Kurt. Cool. Classic.2 — Some tracks are pure genius—and truly exceed those on its era-defining predecessor. A few tracks are a bit more challenging to embrace.3 — I don’t know what “aqua seafoam shame” is, but I love it—and every other sad, drug-soaked image in the closing track. No apologies necessary.

VERDICT

I have a love-hate relationship with a few tracks, but the record is gangbusters.

3P-041 — Black Eyed Man (1992)

Cowboy Junkies

1 — A must-listen from Canada’s sibling band exploring America’s South.2 — Michael Timmins’ hypnotic guitar casts a spell. But it’s Margo Timmins’ raspy vocals that take you to that other place. A lot of singers have pipes—but there is only one Margo Timmins.3 — Don’t believe the 3P hype—Horse in the Country, Oregon Hill, and Southern Rain. You’re welcome.

VERDICT

This is how I discovered the Junkies. Saddle up and ride away.

3P-043 — Weezer (1994)

Weezer

1 — A staple in most collections, the blue album that ushered in geek rock holds up surprisingly strong today. And yeah, Sweater Song still rocks…2 — Without a doubt, there is no greater 1990s guitar hook than the crescendo of Buddy Holly —Baarrrn-Naarrr-Naarrr-Naar-Naar-Naar-Narr—You know what I’m talking about.3 — Say It Ain’t So is an alt-rock jewel—Turn it up, primal scream, clench your fists, even drink a glass of milk and not wipe the excess off your face!

VERDICT

The world has turned and this album is still here—and astounding. Revisit and reassert your inner nerd.

Three POINTS2000s

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-007 — Open (2001)

Cowboy Junkies

1 — May be Cowboy Junkies’ finest moment.2 — If Sweet Jane is the introduction, I Did It All for You is the closer. You can’t go back.3 — The album is a scare and a love letter. How does Margo evoke fear and love at the same time??

VERDICT

Dim the lights, take a deep breath, and relax. Keep heavy on rotation.

3P-012 — Funeral (2004)

Arcade Fire

1 — Prepare for the chills: the opening notes…then the first lyric…oh yeah, we’re going somewhere….but it builds, and it builds….we’re on a journey but now I’m scared about going there…but I can’t turn away.2 — If any song in music has the depth of an entire album, it’s Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels).3 — A masterful debut that hasn’t lost a beat, particularly the coda of Crown of Love.

VERDICT

An impassioned voyage of sound and lyrics that by the end you may need a seat…boy what a ride.

3P-035 — Absolution (2003)

Muse

1 — A nonstop barrage of sound—Muse making it clear early they have something to say, loudly.2 — Stockholm Syndrome spirals, Falling Away with You aches, and nothing small about The Small Print.3 — Apocalypse Please is absolutely bonkers.

VERDICT

Off its rocker. Proclaim eternal victory.

3P-039 — Tonight (2009)

Franz Ferdinand

1 — Groovy third outing from the UK’s hidden pearl that leaves you asking—how do I not know this?2 — Ulysses—opening bass, the build, the whisper, then the trip. Find a new way, baby!3 — Synthesizer galore—Can’t Stop Feeling, Live Alone, and the 8-minute rave-alternative opus, Lucid Dreams.

VERDICT

Take a break from Radiohead and check this out. Skip if you dislike synths.

Three POINTS2010s

• Home
• About
• Archive

Three POINTS2020s

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-008 — Kiss All the Time. Disco, Occasionally (2026)

Harry Styles

1 — If you’re all about classic rock and Radiohead, but still musically curious, check this one out right now!2 — Paint by numbers, Coming up Roses, and Taste Back show depth that confirms HS is more than a pop star.3 — Hard to stop playing once started.

VERDICT

Modern classic. Gen X listen at least five times before judgment.

3P-045 — WE (2022)

Arcade Fire

1 — WE striking a chord not heard since The Suburbs.2 — Why can’t all new Arcade Fire capture the moment like Lightning I and II3 — Unconditional I is the pick me up we all need.

VERDICT

“Nothing is ever perfect,” but solid AF record. Worth a few spins.

3P-005 — Revolver (1966)

The Beatles

1 — It doesn’t get much better than this.2 — Without Revolver, there’d be no Dark Side, no Nevermind, no Radiohead…and no Beatles that we worship today.3 — The juxtaposition of Here, There, and Everywhere, Yellow Submarine, and She Said She Said….[speechless jaw drop]

VERDICT

My all-time favorite. ‘Nuff said.

3P-019 — The Beatles (White Album) (1968)

The Beatles

1 — The double record every artist really wants to emulate. The rare record that grows with you. The unique record you never hear the same twice. You really can’t stop your brain.2 — Too many masterpieces to reference but George’s short guitar solo on Happiness is a Warm Gun may be one of his greatest.3 — So many tears I was searching, so many tears I was wasting… oh. OH!

VERDICT

There is no album like the White Album. And there never will be.

3P-020 — Abbey Road (1969)

The Beatles

1 — The album that’s something so heavy, and ended a once-in-a-lifetime musical revolution. An undefinable classic.2 — The opener…the George explosions…the medley….the closer…the belly full of wine. ‘Nuff said.3 — Even the cover art is the greatest.

VERDICT

It doesn’t get much better than this. Oh, that magic feeling.

3P-006 — Wish You Were Here (1975)

Pink Floyd

1 — How can you follow Dark Side of the Moon? The answer is here in 5 songs.2 — Gilmour and that guitar!! Which one’s Pink? Fishbowl living. Shining on your seer of visions….whoa…3 — Melt away during the bookends of Shine on…and relish the juicy depth in between.

VERDICT

Put on repeat…forever.

3P-017 — Dark Side of the Moon (1973)

Pink Floyd

1 — First there was Sgt. Pepper, then there was Dark Side….2 — If you don’t know this one, you definitely died before 1973. Or you were really drunk at the time….3 — Everything under the sun is in tune.

VERDICT

One of the greatest of all time. Never gets old. Timeless forever. Home, home again.

3P-049 — Obscured by Clouds (1972)

Pink Floyd

1 — This is the Pink Floyd album before Dark Side.2 — Hot off of Meddle, OBC is a radical departure from the breadth of Echoes and One of These Days. Replete with pop-length songs and more conventional arrangements, but by no means a sneak peek of DSOTM.3 — Wot’s…Uh the Deal rises to the level of Wish You Were Here, and if released after Dark Side, this track may have surpassed it in popularity. Top ten Floyd song of all time.

VERDICT

Definitely worth listening to the album that preceded the magnum opus.

3P-012 — Funeral (2004)

Arcade Fire

1 — Prepare for the chills: the opening notes…then the first lyric…oh yeah, we’re going somewhere….but it builds, and it builds….we’re on a journey but now I’m scared about going there…but I can’t turn away.2 — If any song in music has the depth of an entire album, it’s Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels).3 — A masterful debut that hasn’t lost a beat, particularly the coda of Crown of Love.

VERDICT

An impassioned voyage of sound and lyrics that by the end you may need a seat…boy what a ride.

3P-045 — WE (2022)

Arcade Fire

1 — WE striking a chord not heard since The Suburbs.2 — Why can’t all new Arcade Fire capture the moment like Lightning I and II3 — Unconditional I is the pick me up we all need.

VERDICT

“Nothing is ever perfect,” but solid AF record. Worth a few spins.

Three POINTSBilly JOEL

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-001 — Turnstiles (1976)

Billy Joel

1 — Billy Joel’s understated masterpiece that quietly rivals The Stranger, if not surpasses it.2 — This may be his finest collection of songs on one album. Say Goodbye to Hollywood—quotable and full of hellos and goodbyes. Summer, Highland Falls—his most underrated track. Prelude/Angry Young Man—with one of the greatest (and fastest) piano intros ever. And New York State of Mind—an anthem.3 — And then there was I’ve Loved These Days. Every line is a soundbite. Still feels written for today. Sing it loud.

VERDICT

An underappreciated classic. Impeccable from beginning to end.

3P-026 — The Nylon Curtain (1982)

Billy Joel

1 — Less appreciated Billy Joel classic album that deserves real love. On par with 52nd Street and Glass Houses, but never in the same conversation.2 — Following up Glass Houses (and Songs in the Attic) should be no easy feat, but Billy’s experimental, Beatle-esque record is a tour de force with the classics you love—Pressure, Goodnight Saigon, Allentown—and the classics you don’t know yet—Surprises, She’s Right on Time…3 — And then there’s Laura—how this is not Billy’s most popular song is beyond comprehension. Turn it up loud.

VERDICT

The last Billy Joel record before the Brinkley pivot deserves more attention than it gets. Take my Peter Pan advice.

Three POINTSCowboy JUNKIES

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-007 — Open (2001)

Cowboy Junkies

1 — May be Cowboy Junkies’ finest moment.2 — If Sweet Jane is the introduction, I Did It All for You is the closer. You can’t go back.3 — The album is a scare and a love letter. How does Margo evoke fear and love at the same time??

VERDICT

Dim the lights, take a deep breath, and relax. Keep heavy on rotation.

3P-041 — Black Eyed Man (1992)

Cowboy Junkies

1 — A must-listen from Canada’s sibling band exploring America’s South.2 — Michael Timmins’ hypnotic guitar casts a spell. But it’s Margo Timmins’ raspy vocals that take you to that other place. A lot of singers have pipes—but there is only one Margo Timmins.3 — Don’t believe the 3P hype—Horse in the Country, Oregon Hill, and Southern Rain. You’re welcome.

VERDICT

This is how I discovered the Junkies. Saddle up and ride away.

Three POINTSJohn LENNON

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-024 — Double Fantasy (1980)

John Lennon, Yoko Ono

1 -- Love half the album. Wish I could love the other half.2 -- The opening bells. Signature opener. For those who love John…a smile from the sinister opening bells on Plastic Ono Band.3 -- Watching the Wheels. It’s more than a song: It’s John. And for newbies, it’s fuckin’ amazing.

VERDICT

Not a perfect record but a glimpse into a legend’s third act and what should have been.

3P-047 — Plastic Ono Band (1970)

John Lennon

1 — The ultimate catharsis record. If you’re sad, mad, or simply lost, listen to this record and hold on—it’s going to be alright.2 — Look at me, here I am…
I don’t expect you to understand…
I was the walrus, but now I’m John…
I just got to tell you, goodbye…
The dream is over…And that’s just a sample of his pain.3 — Plastic Ono Band is more than a collection of Lennon songs. It’s John’s soul exposed and laid bare for the world to see post-Beatles breakup. It’s scary and it’s beautiful.

VERDICT

A masterpiece. Contrary to popular belief, this is the best Beatle solo record of 1970.

Three POINTSLed ZEPPELIN

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-025 — Led Zeppelin III (1970)

Led Zeppelin

1 — The Zep bridge album between the all-time classic and the pinnacle of rock.2 — Iconic opener. That riff, that Scream, that beat. Don’t need to be a Zep fan to recognize this.3 — Tangerine is one of the band’s greats. If any other band created Tangerine, even if it was their only hit, they’d go down in rock history. For Zeppelin, Tangerine is just another song in a very large ocean of preeminence.

VERDICT

The third record sometimes gets lost in Zep’s legendary run through Physical Graffiti, but it deserves some attention too.

3P-050 — Led Zeppelin (1969)

Led Zeppelin

1 — Arguably the greatest drum intro of all time. And I don’t care what the neighbors say.2 — Lots of keyboard solos in rock, but none sound remotely like how John Paul Jones killed it on Your Time Is Gonna Come. Not to mention that this song is one of the great “fuck you” songs ever recorded.3 — While Zep I is mostly balls to the wall, Black Mountain Side is a hypnotic trance-like interlude. Close your eyes and let Page take you away.

VERDICT

Come on, it’s Zeppelin’s debut. Good times only.

Three POINTSPaul MCCARTNEY

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-028 — Flaming Pie (1997)

Paul McCartney

1 — Whoa, where did this Paul record come from? Fresh off the Beatles Anthology, Paul drops his most confident record in decades—echoing the spirit of early 1970s Macca.2 — Great Day—Could sit on Ram without blinking. Simple as that.3 — Beautiful Night—Ringo and George Martin back in the room. Modest lyrics, but the arrangement is flawless. Lordy, lordy.

VERDICT

An unexpected late-career gem. Not perfect—but far better than it has any right to be.

3P-048 — Ram (1971)

Paul McCartney, Linda McCartney

1 — Unappreciated in its time—seminal today. Without Ram, there’d be no R.E.M., no Wilco, and the like. Don’t believe me, just check out Eat at Home. Or Too Many People. Or just the whole album.2 — Seriously, is Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey Paul’s best song ever? I’m not saying your favorite, I’m saying his best. What plane of genius was Paul on when he wrote that? To listen to that song again for the very first time—and not know what’s to come—would be a delight.3 — And on top of Ram’s poetic mastery, it’s Paul’s anger letter to John. Oh dear boy!

VERDICT

Contrary to popular belief, this is the greatest solo Beatles record of all time. Yeah, I said it! [gauntlet thrown]

Three POINTSThe Rolling STONES

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-009 — Let it Bleed (1969)

The Rolling Stones

1 — One of the great album openings ever. Opening riff of Gimme Shelter and we’re off.2 — Title track is the Stones off their rocker! Give those lyrics a second listen…sounds like quite a trip.3 — First piano notes of Monkey Man and you know the Stones did it again. Sublime.

VERDICT

While not perfect, this overlooked gem deserves more cred than it gets. Give it what it needs!

3P-037 — Sticky Fingers (1971)

The Rolling Stones

1 — The perfect Stones concoction on one record—though some may exile me for Main Street.2 — That opening riff of Brown Sugar. Buhh! Buhh! Buh-buh-ba-bu-h!!! Whoo!!!3 — Can’t You Hear Me Knocking? Fuck yeah we can.

VERDICT

Drunk, juiced up, and sloppy—in the best way. One of the Stones’ all-time gangbusters!

Three POINTSXXXX

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-019 — The Beatles (White Album) (1968)

The Beatles

1 — The double record every artist really wants to emulate. The rare record that grows with you. The unique record you never hear the same twice. You really can’t stop your brain.2 — Too many masterpieces to reference but George’s short guitar solo on Happiness is a Warm Gun may be one of his greatest.3 — So many tears I was searching, so many tears I was wasting… oh. OH!

VERDICT

There is no album like the White Album. And there never will be.

3P-027 — Bookends (1968)

Simon & Garfunkel

1 — Coo-coo-ca-choo, Mrs. Robinson. Without a doubt the second-best S&G record. Don’t get too comfortable with the acoustic opener—this thing turns quickly: a trippy dilemma, idiosyncratic zoo animals, and the “blah, blah, blah….”2 — Greyhound bus. New Jersey Turnpike. Empty and aching and don’t know why—perfection.3 — More Old Friends. Less Voices of Old People. You’ll know it when you hear it. Permission to skip.

VERDICT

It may not be Bridge Over Troubled Water, but this one delivers—start to finish, minus one.

Three POINTS1969

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-009 — Let it Bleed (1969)

The Rolling Stones

1 — One of the great album openings ever. Opening riff of Gimme Shelter and we’re off.2 — Title track is the Stones off their rocker! Give those lyrics a second listen…sounds like quite a trip.3 — First piano notes of Monkey Man and you know the Stones did it again. Sublime.

VERDICT

While not perfect, this overlooked gem deserves more cred than it gets. Give it what it needs!

3P-020 — Abbey Road (1969)

The Beatles

1 — The album that’s something so heavy, and ended a once-in-a-lifetime musical revolution. An undefinable classic.2 — The opener…the George explosions…the medley….the closer…the belly full of wine. ‘Nuff said.3 — Even the cover art is the greatest.

VERDICT

It doesn’t get much better than this. Oh, that magic feeling.

3P-050 — Led Zeppelin (1969)

Led Zeppelin

1 — Arguably the greatest drum intro of all time. And I don’t care what the neighbors say.2 — Lots of keyboard solos in rock, but none sound remotely like how John Paul Jones killed it on Your Time Is Gonna Come. Not to mention that this song is one of the great “fuck you” songs ever recorded.3 — While Zep I is mostly balls to the wall, Black Mountain Side is a hypnotic trance-like interlude. Close your eyes and let Page take you away.

VERDICT

Come on, it’s Zeppelin’s debut. Good times only.

Three POINTS1966

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-005 — Revolver (1966)

The Beatles

1 — It doesn’t get much better than this.2 — Without Revolver, there’d be no Dark Side, no Nevermind, no Radiohead…and no Beatles that we worship today.3 — The juxtaposition of Here, There, and Everywhere, Yellow Submarine, and She Said She Said….[speechless jaw drop]

VERDICT

My all-time favorite. ‘Nuff said.

Three POINTS1967

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-021 — Are You Experienced (1967)

The Jimi Hendrix Experience

1 -- Iconic opener. Two notes. Instantly memorable.2 -- If a waterfall sounded like an electric guitar led trio, Jimi nailed it.3 -- A fine debut for a guitarist who changed the game.

VERDICT

Move over Rover and let Jimi take over….what else is there to say!

3P-040 — The Doors (1967)

The Doors

1 — The debut that put the Doors on the map—with permanent marker.2 — You know that signature electric piano? It starts here. And yes—this is the one with Light My Fire.3 — The End. Oedipal masterpiece.

VERDICT

Slip into unconsciousness again and again. I’ll meet you at the back of the blue bus.

Three POINTS1970

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-025 — Led Zeppelin III (1970)

Led Zeppelin

1 -- The Zep bridge album between the all-time classic and the pinnacle of rock.2 -- Iconic opener. That riff, that Scream, that beat. Don’t need to be a Zep fan to recognize this.3 --Tangerine is one of the band’s greats. If any other band created Tangerine, even if it was their only hit, they’d go down in rock history. For Zeppelin, Tangerine is just another song in a very large ocean of preeminence.

VERDICT

The third record sometimes gets lost in Zep’s legendary run through Physical Graffiti, but it deserves some attention too.

3P-038 — Moondance (1970)

Van Morrison

1 — Oh the water!!! No other Van album tops this one. Not many classics are truly flawless—Moondance is.2 — Go beyond the ones you know—Glad tidings from New York, caravans painted red and white, fantabulous night to make romance.3 — Into the Mystic
. No need to comment further. Listen, love—too late to stop now.

VERDICT

Whether it rocks your gypsy soul or stones you to your soul, come running. Turn it up.

3P-047 — Plastic Ono Band (1970)

John Lennon

1 — The ultimate catharsis record. If you’re sad, mad, or simply lost, listen to this record and hold on—it’s going to be alright.2 — Look at me, here I am…
I don’t expect you to understand…
I was the walrus, but now I’m John…
I just got to tell you, goodbye…
The dream is over…And that’s just a sample of his pain.3 — Plastic Ono Band is more than a collection of Lennon songs. It’s John’s soul exposed and laid bare for the world to see post-Beatles breakup. It’s scary and it’s beautiful.

VERDICT

A masterpiece. Contrary to popular belief, this is the best Beatle solo record of 1970.

3P-018 — The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars (1972)

David Bowie

1 — The opener that changes everything…we’re on to something new. Is Earth really dying?2 — How can you describe an album that turned rock in its head. You can’t. Just listen.3 — Starman will give you chills; Moonage Daydream will make you jump; Rock n Roll Suicide will have you screaming for more. And those are not even the “hits.”

VERDICT

70s zeitgeist. League of its own. Wham bam thank you ma’am!

3P-023 — Hot August Night (1972)

Neil Diamond

1 -- Masterful live double album showcasing a roller coaster of sound and lyrics. A singer-songwriter at his greatest power.2 -- Opening track: What is this chatter…are they practicing…..wait, the show has started…..I thought this was a man on his guitar?...What are these strings?….shh! Shut up and listen! And that organ piping in, the acoustic guitar, the deepest drums—bum bum bum bum-bum-bum….the clackety-clack, and then the CRESCENDO. And that the electric guitar…THE APPLAUSE! And the first note Neil sings, da da dee dom. And then it’s for the races…3 -- I am…I said is one of the most powerful performances recorded live. What a finish to that one. I wish I was there.

VERDICT

Let me hear that, let me near that. Uncanny live album recording of what legends are made of. You can’t just listen. You awaken.

3P-049 — Obscured by Clouds (1972)

Pink Floyd

1 — This is the Pink Floyd album before Dark Side.2 — Hot off of Meddle, OBC is a radical departure from the breadth of Echoes and One of These Days. Replete with pop-length songs and more conventional arrangements, but by no means a sneak peek of DSOTM.3 — Wot’s…Uh the Deal rises to the level of Wish You Were Here, and if released after Dark Side, this track may have surpassed it in popularity. Top ten Floyd song of all time.

VERDICT

Definitely worth listening to the album that preceded the magnum opus.

3P-013 — Who’s Next (1971)

The Who

1 — Meet the new boss, same as the old boss: Not many artists can say the follow-up to their signature album is even better. The Who can…2 — Oh and that opener….the synth….three piano notes… Keith’s drums…Roger’s first lyric…John’s root….and then Pete’s riff….and stop! Don’t cry, it’s just teenage wasteland….3 — A flawless track list with multiple anthems of a generation. And an infamous album cover to boot—peeing on a stone monolith.

VERDICT

Right in tune. Play it loud. Play it often.

3P-022 — Tapestry (1971)

Carole King

1 -- Landmark singer-songwriter release. For newbies, the “where have I heard that before” record.2 -- If love doesn’t strike by the opener, Cupid hits hard by So Far Away.3 -- Many emulate. Few replicate. Carole hit this out of the park to the land where the honey runs.

VERDICT

Required listening. Feel the Earth move with this one.

3P-037 — Sticky Fingers (1971)

The Rolling Stones

1 — The perfect Stones concoction on one record—though some may exile me for Main Street.2 — That opening riff of Brown Sugar. Buhh! Buhh! Buh-buh-ba-bu-h!!! Whoo!!!3 — Can’t You Hear Me Knocking? Fuck yeah we can.

VERDICT

Drunk, juiced up, and sloppy—in the best way. One of the Stones’ all-time gangbusters!

3P-048 — Ram (1971)

Paul McCartney, Linda McCartney

1 — Unappreciated in its time—seminal today. Without Ram, there’d be no R.E.M., no Wilco, and the like. Don’t believe me, just check out Eat at Home. Or Too Many People. Or just the whole album.2 — Seriously, is Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey Paul’s best song ever? I’m not saying your favorite, I’m saying his best. What plane of genius was Paul on when he wrote that? To listen to that song again for the very first time—and not know what’s to come—would be a delight.3 — And on top of Ram’s poetic mastery, it’s Paul’s anger letter to John. Oh dear boy!

VERDICT

Contrary to popular belief, this is the greatest solo Beatles record of all time. Yeah, I said it! [gauntlet thrown]

Three POINTS1973

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-017 — Dark Side of the Moon (1973)

Pink Floyd

1 — First there was Sgt. Pepper, then there was Dark Side….2 — If you don’t know this one, you definitely died before 1973. Or you were really drunk at the time….3 — Everything under the sun is in tune.

VERDICT

One of the greatest of all time. Never gets old. Timeless forever. Home, home again.

Three POINTS1974

• Home
• About
• Archive

Three POINTS1975

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-006 — Wish You Were Here (1975)

Pink Floyd

1 — How can you follow Dark Side of the Moon? The answer is here in 5 songs.2 — Gilmour and that guitar!! Which one’s Pink? Fishbowl living. Shining on your seer of visions….whoa…3 — Melt away during the bookends of Shine on…and relish the juicy depth in between.

VERDICT

Put on repeat…forever.

3P-032 — Blood on the Tracks (1975)

Bob Dylan

1 — Smack dab in the middle of Dylan’s ’70s renaissance. Oh, this is a good one.2 — That opening acoustic guitar—you know the song. Sit back, you’re on a Dylan odyssey. “Working for a while on a fishing boat right outside of Delacroix.” It may be his finest.3 — These songs ache, weep, and bleed. A lyrical tour de force—it’s a wonder I even know how to breathe.

VERDICT

Hands down, in the top echelon of Dylan. But if you love lyrics, this one may be tip-top. Listen carefully.

Three POINTS1976

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-001 — Turnstiles (1976)

Billy Joel

1 — Billy Joel’s understated masterpiece that quietly rivals The Stranger, if not surpasses it.2 — This may be his finest collection of songs on one album. Say Goodbye to Hollywood—quotable and full of hellos and goodbyes. Summer, Highland Falls—his most underrated track. Prelude/Angry Young Man—with one of the greatest (and fastest) piano intros ever. And New York State of Mind—an anthem.3 — And then there was I’ve Loved These Days. Every line is a soundbite. Still feels written for today. Sing it loud.

VERDICT

An underappreciated classic. Impeccable from beginning to end.

Three POINTS1977

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-004 — Rumours (1977)

Fleetwood Mac

1 — An artistic - and highly commercial - classic for the ages.2 — How do you not get jazzed when Second Hand News amps up?3 — The excellence is endless: flawless songs, real heartbreak, no filler.

VERDICT

Bam-bam ba-ba-bam bam bam bam—must own!

Three POINTS1980

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-024 — Double Fantasy (1980)

John Lennon, Yoko Ono

1 -- Love half the album. Wish I could love the other half.2 -- The opening bells. Signature opener. For those who love John…a smile from the sinister opening bells on Plastic Ono Band.3 -- Watching the Wheels. It’s more than a song: It’s John. And for newbies, it’s fuckin’ amazing.

VERDICT

Not a perfect record but a glimpse into a legend’s third act and what should have been.

Three POINTS1982

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-016 — Thriller (1982)

Michael Jackson

1 —One of the highest selling records of all time.2 — More than half the songs are etched into pop music history3 — The opening synth to Billy Jean is burned in most people’s brains.

VERDICT

If you don’t know it, you lived in a society without music.

3P-026 — The Nylon Curtain (1982)

Billy Joel

1 — Less appreciated Billy Joel classic album that deserves real love. On par with 52nd Street and Glass Houses, but never in the same conversation.2 — Following up Glass Houses (and Songs in the Attic) should be no easy feat, but Billy’s experimental, Beatle-esque record is a tour de force with the classics you love—Pressure, Goodnight Saigon, Allentown—and the classics you don’t know yet—Surprises, She’s Right on Time…3 — And then there’s Laura—how this is not Billy’s most popular song is beyond comprehension. Turn it up loud.

VERDICT

The last Billy Joel record before the Brinkley pivot deserves more attention than it gets. Take my Peter Pan advice.

3P-029 — Imperial Bedroom (1982)

Elvis Costello, The Attractions

1 — Another apex from the most underrated rock star. Elvis is king.2 — One of the great album openers—and it’s not even his best. Few albums don’t have a skip—this is one of them.3 — And then there’s Man Out of Time—the WTF primal scream, the crazed guitar, the return to the classic Attractions sound. But wait…what is he even singing about? Take a listen—and ask if you’ll still love a man out of time.

VERDICT

Beyond belief. Start to finish.

3P-033 — Singles–45’s and Under (1982)

Squeeze

1 — Classic greatest hits record from one of the most underrated bands—and songwriters—in rock history. Every song on this sampler is a can’t miss.2 — Tellies, Tenners, Tellies, and Nappies—there are songs with stories to tell, and in a league of its own, there’s Up the Junction.3 — You know Tempted. You love Tempted. Now go meet the rest.

VERDICT

Definitely cool for cats. Explore this band and feel the need for Squeeze.

Three POINTS1983

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-015 — Genesis (Self-Titled) (1983)

Genesis

1 — Oh mama – the last Genesis record before the band goes full commercial.2 — Home by the Sea rivals Abacab as peak Collins era. Home by the Sea takes you down a far more sinister musical voyage, but nothing as sinister as the Collins’ laugh in Mama.3 — Conversely, half the album is bright and a sign of what’s to come. But Silver Rainbow doesn’t get enough love.

VERDICT

Enjoy the final bow of classic Genesis. That’s all.

3P-036 — Synchronicity (1983)

The Police

1 — Lyrical metaphors everywhere—but nothing hits like rush hour: lemmings packed in shiny metal boxes.2 — Mother—no. Miss Gradenko—yes. Synchronicity I and II—more.3 — Like it or not, there’d be no Radiohead without Murder by Numbers. Andy Summers’ guitar here is the birth of Johnny Greenwood.

VERDICT

Mighty swan song from the greatest rock trio. This little black spot on the sun burnt out too soon.

3P-042 — War (1983)

U2

1 — U2’s standout third outing is a kick-ass, take no prisoners, mother-effin rock show that’s a must-have in any collection.2 — Not many albums open stronger than Sunday Bloody Sunday—let alone a generational anthem. Mullen’s drums. The Edge’s guitar. Alright, let’s go.3 — “How long must we sing this song?”
...“How long to sing this song?”
Answer: like a song you have to sing.

VERDICT

The golden age. Sing it loud, play it again—and maybe stop to dance.

3P-044 — Violent Femmes (1983)

Violent Femmes

1 — Add Blister in the Sun to list of all-time iconic album openers. Its distinctive opening riff can be named in five notes.2 — Wanna let out your frustrations… Listen to Kiss Off loud and belt out every word.3 — This album answers the age old question: Why can’t I get just one fuck?

VERDICT

"10,10,10,10 for everything everything, everything, everything, everything!!!”

Three POINTS1984

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-003 — Legend (1984 Compilation)

Bob Marley & The Wailers

1 — Essential staple of any music collection.2 — No single track rises above the others — they’re all classics.3 — In an era full of “best of” albums, this one is genuinely flawless.

VERDICT

Listening required - Must have for those who don’t have.

3P-010 — Purple Rain (1984)

Prince & The Revolution

1 — Dearly beloved, we may have the best opening track ever. Four enchanting minutes of pure catharsis.2 — It doesn’t stop…Take Me With U, Beautiful Ones…and that’s just side one. Side two...oh God yes.3 — This belongs in the highest echelon of 20th century artistry.

VERDICT

Perfect album. Rare and beautiful.

3P-011 — 1984 (1984)

Van Halen

1 — Feel the 80s synth flow and Jump! It’s ok, I’ll Wait.2 — Drop Dead Legs—classic Eddie and David Lee….strong as any earlier track.3 — Opening drums to kick off side two. Doesn’t get much better than this.

VERDICT

Not I or II, but quintessential for its time. Don’t forget to come back to this one. Class dismissed.

Three POINTS1986

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-034 — So (1986)

Peter Gabriel

1 — Peter Gabriel’s commercial peak—and it was about time. Arguably the last great album of the 1980–1986 era.2 — “Let the red rain pour down on me…” Helluva opener. If this doesn’t grab you, change the record.3 — That Voice Again…play it again. Maybe the finest song here—though some will hit me with a sledgehammer for that.

VERDICT

It may not be Biko or Games Without Frontiers, but so what. Primo record.

3P-046 — Graceland (1986)

Paul Simon

1 — 80s staple that is pure joy and so much more than the songs you know.2 — Best accordion album intro in the history of rock and roll!3 — I Know What I Know is the secret high point of this record—and I do know you from the cinematographer’s party.

VERDICT

Make the pilgrimage to Graceland.

Three POINTS1992

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-014 — Automatic for the People (1992)

R.E.M.

1 — Hey kids, rock n roll….R.E.M.’s apex of their most dominant decade.2 — From the first guitar riff, R.E.M. is sending a clear message—this is not your shiny happy people. The musical pivot makes this album feel timeless.3 — R.E.M. has so many classics but Find the River should enter that conversation.

VERDICT

Ollie Ollie Ollie. Own it, love it, repeat.

3P-041 — Black Eyed Man (1992)

Cowboy Junkies

1 — A must-listen from Canada’s sibling band exploring America’s South.2 — Michael Timmins’ hypnotic guitar casts a spell. But it’s Margo Timmins’ raspy vocals that take you to that other place. A lot of singers have pipes—but there is only one Margo Timmins.3 — Don’t believe the 3P hype—Horse in the Country, Oregon Hill, and Southern Rain. You’re welcome.

VERDICT

This is how I discovered the Junkies. Saddle up and ride away.

Three POINTS1993

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-030 — Siamese Dream (1993)

The Smashing Pumpkins

1 — This is The Smashing Pumpkins’ zenith. Nothing from that era sounds like this album.2 — Soma is from a brave new world. Mayonaise is delicious. Today is the greatest.3 — The closer, Luna, leaves you wanting more. Yes, I’m so in love with you (so in love).

VERDICT

Trippy, heavy, and an absolute dream. Play it loud.

3P-031 — In Utero (1993)

Nirvana

1 — Kurt. Cool. Classic.2 — Some tracks are pure genius—and truly exceed those on its era-defining predecessor. A few tracks are a bit more challenging to embrace.3 — I don’t know what “aqua seafoam shame” is, but I love it—and every other sad, drug-soaked image in the closing track. No apologies necessary.

VERDICT

I have a love-hate relationship with a few tracks, but the record is gangbusters.

Three POINTS1994

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-043 — Weezer (1994)

Weezer

1 — A staple in most collections, the blue album that ushered in geek rock holds up surprisingly strong today. And yeah, Sweater Song still rocks…2 — Without a doubt, there is no greater 1990s guitar hook than the crescendo of Buddy Holly —Baarrrn-Naarrr-Naarrr-Naar-Naar-Naar-Narr—You know what I’m talking about.3 — Say It Ain’t So is an alt-rock jewel—Turn it up, primal scream, clench your fists, even drink a glass of milk and not wipe the excess off your face!

VERDICT

The world has turned and this album is still here—and astounding. Revisit and reassert your inner nerd.

Three POINTS1997

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-002 — OK Computer (1997)

Radiohead

1 — The beginning of the Radiohead revolution.2 — Paranoid Android’s haunting middle 8 grabs you and lever let’s go.3 — While Nevermind may be the crown jewel of the 1990s, OK Computer may be its Sgt. Pepper.

VERDICT

Listen now - with headphones.

3P-028 — Flaming Pie (1997)

Paul McCartney

1 — Whoa, where did this Paul record come from? Fresh off the Beatles Anthology, Paul drops his most confident record in decades—echoing the spirit of early 1970s Macca.2 — Great Day—Could sit on Ram without blinking. Simple as that.3 — Beautiful Night—Ringo and George Martin back in the room. Modest lyrics, but the arrangement is flawless. Lordy, lordy.

VERDICT

An unexpected late-career gem. Not perfect—but far better than it has any right to be.

Three POINTS2001

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-007 — Open (2001)

Cowboy Junkies

1 — May be Cowboy Junkies’ finest moment.2 — If Sweet Jane is the introduction, I Did It All for You is the closer. You can’t go back.3 — The album is a scare and a love letter. How does Margo evoke fear and love at the same time??

VERDICT

Dim the lights, take a deep breath, and relax. Keep heavy on rotation.

Three POINTS2003

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-035 — Absolution (2003)

Muse

1 — A nonstop barrage of sound—Muse making it clear early they have something to say, loudly.2 — Stockholm Syndrome spirals, Falling Away with You aches, and nothing small about The Small Print.3 — Apocalypse Please is absolutely bonkers.

VERDICT

Off its rocker. Proclaim eternal victory.

Three POINTS19xx

• Home
• About
• Archive

• Browse
• Back to Year
• Reviews

3P-012 — Funeral (2004)

Arcade Fire

1 — Prepare for the chills: the opening notes…then the first lyric…oh yeah, we’re going somewhere….but it builds, and it builds….we’re on a journey but now I’m scared about going there…but I can’t turn away.2 — If any song in music has the depth of an entire album, it’s Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels).3 — A masterful debut that hasn’t lost a beat, particularly the coda of Crown of Love.

VERDICT

An impassioned voyage of sound and lyrics that by the end you may need a seat…boy what a ride.

Three POINTS2009

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-039 — Tonight (2009)

Franz Ferdinand

1 — Groovy third outing from the UK’s hidden pearl that leaves you asking—how do I not know this?2 — Ulysses—opening bass, the build, the whisper, then the trip. Find a new way, baby!3 — Synthesizer galore—Can’t Stop Feeling, Live Alone, and the 8-minute rave-alternative opus, Lucid Dreams.

VERDICT

Take a break from Radiohead and check this out. Skip if you dislike synths.

33P-045 — WE (2022)

Arcade Fire

1 — WE striking a chord not heard since The Suburbs.2 — Why can’t all new Arcade Fire capture the moment like Lightning I and II3 — Unconditional I is the pick me up we all need.

VERDICT

“Nothing is ever perfect,” but solid AF record. Worth a few spins.

Three POINTS2026

• Home
• About
• Archive

3P-008 — Kiss All the Time. Disco, Occasionally (2026)

Harry Styles

1 — If you’re all about classic rock and Radiohead, but still musically curious, check this one out right now!2 — Paint by numbers, Coming up Roses, and Taste Back show depth that confirms HS is more than a pop star.3 — Hard to stop playing once started.

VERDICT

Modern classic. Gen X listen at least five times before judgment.